Modern loyalty programs are undergoing a shift. For years, companies have relied on transactional models, rewarding customers for spending more or visiting often. But consumer behavior suggests this strategy is no longer sufficient to foster meaningful, long-term connections. Today's customers are looking for more than points, discounts, or freebies—they want to align with brands whose actions reflect their own values and priorities. This shift marks the rise of behavioral loyalty, where genuine engagement and value-driven interactions outweigh traditional incentives.
Behavioral loyalty isn’t about how much a customer buys—it’s about how often they engage with your brand in meaningful ways. These actions might include participating in challenges, supporting causes the brand cares about, providing feedback, or referring friends. By rewarding behaviors that align with your brand’s values, you create deeper emotional connections that cultivate advocacy and lasting loyalty. Let’s explore why focusing on customer actions is the key to building stronger, more authentic relationships.
In an age of constant information, consumers are more aware of the impact of their choices than ever before. They don’t just buy products—they invest in brands that mirror their personal beliefs. According to a study by IBM, nearly 70% of consumers prefer brands that align with their values, and 57% are willing to change purchasing habits to reduce environmental impact.
This growing awareness challenges businesses to move beyond discounts and perks. Customers now want to see actions that reinforce a brand's commitment to their stated values. For example, outdoor clothing company Patagonia famously asked customers to buy less and repair their old gear, emphasizing sustainability over profit. The result? A fiercely loyal customer base willing to champion the brand.
To build behavioral loyalty, brands must identify these value-driven behaviors and encourage them in creative, authentic ways.
Shared purpose is the foundation of behavioral loyalty. Consumers connect with brands that demonstrate a commitment to causes they care about, such as sustainability, social justice, or community building. But it’s not enough to talk about these issues—customers expect brands to act on them.
Take Ben & Jerry’s, a brand that actively participates in social justice movements. From launching limited-edition flavors to support specific causes to leveraging their platform to promote voter registration, they’ve made advocacy a central part of their identity. This consistent action reinforces their authenticity, turning customers into advocates who feel like they’re contributing to something bigger by supporting the brand.
Behavioral loyalty thrives when customers feel they’re part of a mission. Brands can amplify this connection by recognizing and rewarding actions that support shared goals. For instance, a loyalty program might reward customers for:
- Participating in community service initiatives.
- Recycling or returning packaging.
- Sharing educational content related to a brand’s mission.
Platforms like Rediem make it easy for brands to incorporate these purpose-driven actions into their loyalty strategies, enabling seamless integration with broader campaigns that inspire engagement.
While rewards programs have traditionally focused on purchases, a growing number of companies are finding success by rewarding non-purchase behaviors. These actions not only foster loyalty but also deepen engagement with the brand.
For example, fitness app Strava taps into behavioral loyalty by rewarding users for logging workouts, setting personal goals, and encouraging others. These activities create a sense of community and accomplishment, making users feel more connected to the brand without a single dollar exchanged.
This approach works because it taps into intrinsic motivation—people want to feel good about their actions. By creating opportunities for customers to engage meaningfully, brands can build a sense of belonging that transcends financial transactions.
Understanding which actions to reward requires a deep understanding of your customers. What drives them? What values do they share with your brand? Identifying these behaviors is a critical first step in crafting a behavioral loyalty strategy.
Start by analyzing customer data to uncover patterns. For example:
What actions correlate with long-term loyalty? These could include attending events, writing reviews, or referring friends.
What values resonate most with your audience? Sustainability, diversity, and wellness are popular themes that can guide your strategy.
How do customers engage with your brand beyond purchasing? Social media interactions, community involvement, or brand advocacy are often overlooked opportunities.
Once you’ve identified key behaviors, design a system that makes it easy and rewarding for customers to participate.
Gamification is a powerful tool for driving behavioral loyalty. By introducing elements like challenges, badges, and leaderboards, brands can make engagement fun and rewarding.
Nike’s Run Club app, for instance, uses gamification to motivate users to run more often. Runners can join challenges, earn virtual medals, and share achievements with their community. These features keep users engaged and encourage them to interact with the brand regularly, creating a habit of loyalty.
The key to effective gamification is aligning challenges with actions that matter to your brand. If sustainability is your focus, create a challenge around reducing waste. If you’re promoting wellness, reward customers for attending fitness classes or sharing healthy recipes. By making these activities enjoyable, you strengthen emotional ties with your audience.
The success of behavioral loyalty programs depends on consistent tracking and analysis. Unlike traditional loyalty programs, which measure transactional data, behavioral loyalty requires a broader view of customer engagement.
Key metrics to monitor include:
How many customers are engaging in the behaviors you’re encouraging?
Are loyal participants staying with your brand longer?
Are customers referring others or sharing your brand on social media?
While behavioral loyalty isn’t solely about sales, it often drives indirect revenue by increasing customer lifetime value.
Regularly reviewing these metrics allows you to refine your strategy and identify which actions drive the greatest loyalty.
One of the most significant advantages of behavioral loyalty is its ability to turn customers into brand advocates. When people feel a deep connection to a brand’s mission, they’re more likely to share it with others.
Consider TOMS, a brand built on the principle of giving back. For every pair of shoes sold, TOMS donates a pair to someone in need. This simple yet powerful model has inspired millions of customers to advocate for the brand, sharing its story with friends and family.
Advocacy like this doesn’t happen by accident—it’s the result of consistently reinforcing a shared purpose through actions. By rewarding meaningful engagement, brands can nurture a loyal customer base that amplifies their message and attracts new followers.
Behavioral loyalty represents a fundamental shift in how brands think about customer relationships. It’s no longer just about rewarding purchases—it’s about recognizing the behaviors that align with your brand’s mission and values.
This approach is particularly powerful for companies looking to stand out in competitive markets. By focusing on actions, brands can build authentic connections that drive loyalty and advocacy in ways traditional rewards programs can’t achieve.
Rediem helps companies embrace this shift by enabling them to design purpose-driven loyalty programs tailored to their values. With tools that track and reward meaningful engagement, brands can create a lasting impact on their customers—and the world.
By investing in behavioral loyalty, businesses have the opportunity to foster deeper connections, inspire advocacy, and ultimately create a community of devoted customers who share their vision for the future.
ready to make the switch? we automatically migrate your customers points from Yotpo, Smile and others so your customers don't miss a beat.
.png){kind=icon}
